About 10 minutes · five short steps
Start here: Look past your first take
A short path through practice already on CritThinker. The aim is to notice when the first thought, or a view you already like, is doing more of the work than the evidence. This is only practice. It is not a test, and it is not a verdict on you.
You can stop after any step and come back. Ticks stay in this browser. No account is needed for the free steps.
Four things you can try free
No account needed.
“The first principle is that you must not fool yourself—and you are the easiest person to fool.”
Ticks on this device
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
1 — Notice the first assumption
This week's Monday mystery is free. No account needed.
Today's mystery is practice in spotting a jump from the first story that comes to mind.
Try this: Play this week's free Monday mystery, The Day Time Stopped. When Dr Fallacy offers a first theory, pause and ask what else could be true.
2 — Look for what would hurt the view
Free to read. No account needed.
We tend to collect what agrees with us, and skim past what would not.
Try this: Read the confirmation bias card. Then, before you look anything up, write down one thing that would change your mind about a view you already like. A fair test is one you could have failed.
3 — Don't fall in love with your idea
Free to read. No account needed.
Attachment to a thought, or certainty that has run ahead of the evidence, can close the view.
Try this: Read tool 5 on the Baloney detection kit, "Don't fall in love with your idea": do not keep a hypothesis because it is yours. Then read the overconfidence card. Pick one idea you thought of yourself and ask what would count against it.
4 — Test a claim you already like
Free. No account needed. Nothing is uploaded.
It is easy to take apart a stranger's case. The useful practice is to test one of your own.
Try this: Open the argument builder. Write a conclusion you already agree with, add the reasons, and mark whether each one is true and enough. If a premise is unsure, leave it marked unsure.
5 — What would change your mind?
This page is free to read. The Socratic practice set is for members.
A claim is sturdier when you can say what would count against it, and stay glad to be shown otherwise.
Try this: Read the five steps on the Socratic method page, and the line from Gorgias. Then take one confident claim of your own and ask: what would change my mind?
"Just as glad, mind you, to be refuted as to refute." (Lamb)Gorgias 458a, Lamb's translation
Train, the library of thinkers and the full tests are included in the 10-day free trial, then membership. Marcus Aurelius, the free scam check and Monday's Trickle stay free. Missing a day is fine. Nothing here is lost.